Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mama Ain't Playin''s avatar

This is a positive essay with good advice about not becoming a single issue "special interest" person. I appreciate your perspective--my husband and I are completely on the same page, but our daughter sometimes gets angry with me when I crack jokes about her "transwoman" roommate. (Because, come on: it's kind of hilarious, and one of the things that I hate about this movement is that its so relentlessly humorless.) But she's in college, and knows that people can't change sex.

However I disagree with your claim that "ending the discussion so dismissively would make me unsafe for them to talk to in the future." Why buy into the idea that WORDS spoken in family conversations could possibly render you "unsafe?" That seems like conceding too much ground. Maybe taking a teasing or a humorous approach would be healthy, in that not everything about this insanity has to be all about death and suicide and threats of "harm?" Opening up other ways of thinking and talking about this--and about people who AREN'T EVEN IN THE ROOM--would be good?

Or, maybe I'm just a jerk. IDK. I'm over this BS. Increasingly my students are too--one even came out to me as a full-on TERF. Remember the 90s, when Eddie Izzard could describe himself as "a male lesbian" and it was a big punchline? Sheesh.

Expand full comment
Average Dad's avatar

Yes, I agree, best to respond with "Interesting, I see it differently" is probably a more open-ended and inviting approach. Tell me more about how that works." Or "I don't understand that, can you explain it to me?". Because most people "think" by talking so we don't ever want people to be shut up or shut out or cancelled. Because we want to "know" what they are thinking, and if they are "thinking" terrible ideas or thoughts we want to bring those out into the light and really discuss those issues thoroughly. It is the Socratic/stoic methodology. This is why our 1st amendment is so important and we should all want to hear what crazy ideas people have so that maybe we can influence their thinking through reasoned debate and questioning, or maybe it is our thinking that could use some new information. We should never silence anyone, let them speak, especially when we don't agree with them. Most people think by talking....you never want to silence people. The authoritarian left types have always wanted to silence dissent and this is a grave mistake. Science is never settled, debate is always beneficial - always. We should be seekers of truth, lovers of truth no matter when it collides with long cherished beliefs we may have, we should always be willing to learn new ideas, new perspectives. Today truth can be hard to find, but we must persist.

Expand full comment
139 more comments...

No posts