Discussion about this post

User's avatar
for the kids's avatar

Thank you for this.

One great article by a detransitioner said: being a woman is not a feeling, it's a fact.

Ditto for men of course.

I think someone's history doesn't change whether they're a woman or man, that's an attribute set by biology...but indeed they can have experiences or feelings more common with the opposite sex in the society and time they are in. I agree our society should just recognize this. The rest is body hatred which is .....not necessarily best dealt with by modifying the body and given all the ways gender dysphoria presents and evolves right now, rapid medicalization for still developing young people or people with complex situations (trauma, etc) is dangerous and wrong.

Expand full comment
LovingMother's avatar

Thank you for this wonderful article. It does seem that there are a tiny number of adult men and an even more infinitesimal number of adult women for whom medicalization may turn out to be the best of bad options after plenty of therapy. However, the normalization and even glamorization of it plus the promotion of a whole ideology to go along with what is a mental illness is damaging all of society. We have done a particular disservice to the young most of whom would never have gone down this hole on their own. I blame in part the excesses of "kind-hearted and progressive" thinking in the schools which has lead kids to be groomed and mentally separated from parents. When "kindness and understanding" promotes self harm, ideology, and turning away from family we have a real problem. I was glad to see you use the word "gaslight".

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts