Contradictions in Trans Ideology - An Incomplete List
"Is the person a child or is the person adult-like? Does the person have a certain type of cognition, morality to make such a choice?"
-Convicted sex trafficker and cult leader Keith Raniere
A short catalogue of nonsensical axioms justifying transition of gender dysphoric children:
1. Trans women are women, yet the trans child is not a child, but rather a sage with perfect understanding and precognition.
2. Gender is a social construct, yet the child’s gender identity arises independent of any social influence.
3. Gender identity is fluid, yet the child’s gender identity is immutable.
4. Gender is non-binary, yet the child is either cis or trans.
5. The body is irrelevant to gender identity, yet the child’s body must be chemically and surgically altered to match the child’s gender identity.
6. Gender non-conformity should be celebrated, yet the child’s body must conform to the child’s gender expression.
7. A child cannot consent to sexual activity with an adult, yet the child can consent to the destruction of healthy sexual organs by an adult.
8. Children who identify as trans are at high risk of suicide, yet the child must be identified as trans to prevent suicide.
Question: what does it mean to be male or female, if unrelated to the body or to societal definitions of masculinity or femininity? Answer: you know, it means you feel male or you feel female. Question: What does male or female mean? Answer: you wouldn't understand, since you're "cis." Question: Why do you need to change your body just because you feel male or feel female if your body has nothing to do with it? Answer: because the mis-match is distressing. Question: why is the mis-match distressing if there is no link between the body and the identity? Answer: you wouldn't understand because you're "cis."
If Gender Clinics actually followed Trans Rights rhetoric in treating 'gender dysphoria'...this is how it would go!
APPOINTMENT:
Patient: Hello, I'm here because I'm dysphoric.
Doctor: Well, what are you dysphoric about?
Patient: Well, I'm a male--
Doctor: AMAB you mean. Go on.
Patient: --y-yes, but I"m a woman inside --
Doctor: And outside. Transwomen are women.
Patient: -- o-of course! But basically I need tits to feel my true self.
Doctor:...Why? Transwomen are women.
Patient: Yeahhh, but women have tits and I dont, so I"m dysphor...
Doctor: Women don't need to have tits to be women.
Patient: O-Okay, but what about my dick? I at least want SRS--
Doctor: Women can have dicks. Also, men can get pregnant. Why are you dysphoric? It sounds like you don't understand what men and women are.
Patient: Well, true that women can have penises and men can have vaginas, but--
Doctor: Indeed, it is true. So your dysphoria is baseless. Now get out of my office.