Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Beeswax's avatar

Thank you for sharing this harrowing story. Although I see the parallels between the social contagion of satanic abuse and the trans craze, I don't share your optimism that the trans craze will wither on the vine and die. Here's why:

1. There's an enormous amount of money being made through the medicalization of people's bodies. The industry of so-called transgender medicine is thriving and has the support of the universities, the medical schools, and the medical journals.

2. There is enormous political influence and power to be garnered on the Democrat/Progressive side through championing this anti-scientific debacle. Our current president has signed the Equality Act, which eradicates the protections of Title IX for biological females, i.e. women, who are no longer a protected class. He speaks openly of supporting the "rights of trans kids." Despite the judicious policies being instituted in Sweden and other Western European countries, here in the States we operate under our own special cloud of progressive arrogance and stupidity.

3. There is huge personal self-aggrandizement available to anybody who supports this cause, and instant cancellation for anyone who opposes it. The satanic panic was promoted by and affected a relatively small group of individuals, but trans ideology is promoted by teachers at every level of education, all the way up to college administrators. The theory of an unlimited number of genders has supplanted the human sexual binary as the basis of human biology. The churches in my progressive neighborhood all have LGBTQ flags and signs plastered on them. Even the U.S. military is willing to go along with gender ideology rather than get involved in a brouhaha with woke activists. Name me one institution of society that has not been infected by it.

4. For each child or young adult who detransitions, there are fifty more being prescribed puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones as I type this. I know some people in their mid-30s who grew up with this ideology, and even though they're not necessarily trans, they accept it wholeheartedly. They take it as basic truth and assume they're all somewhere on the gender spectrum. Capture the minds of children and rule the future.

5. In short, this is a "cause" with so much power and influence that something overwhelmingly catastrophic would have to happen to turn the tide against it on all these institutional levels. I see it lasting indefinitely. You mentioned Jennifer Bilek's research (the 11th Hour Blog), which is a fantastic resource. But do you think the billionaire activists who have invested everything in trans-humanism are intending to drop out and move to a cabin in the woods any time soon?

6. I really hope I'm wrong. What am I missing?

Expand full comment
Matt Osborne's avatar

This is great, and comprehensive, but there is one glaring omission: the name Diane Ehrensaft.

Ehrensaft, you may recall, came to the Satanic Panic rather late in the game, after the Presidio day care case had been debunked, lawsuits settled, and the Army moved on. She insisted that the "recovered memories" of children were real, that patently-absurd memories they reported were real enough, and that the two girls she interviewed were "speaking in tongues" about their prior abuse. Again, she did this AFTER the whole world had moved on.

And what is Diane Ehrensaft doing today? Why, she is one of the most prominent advocates of the "trans child." She has whole presentations on YouTube about "the gender angels" in your kids and the "gender ghosts" that want to make your kids sad with their invalidating sorcery. https://thedistance.substack.com/p/diane-ehrensaft-satanic-panic-woo

Expand full comment
88 more comments...