Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Craig Green's avatar

Thanks for this informative and heartening essay. I've long puzzled over how the pro-trans ideology denies and dismisses the role of social contagion in the burgeoning numbers of trans youth. Pretty much everything in our cultural life spreads by contagion: religions, cultural trends, ethics, conspiracy theories.... Our inability to wisely navigate the currents of social contagion (which have shaped us at least as long as we've had language) threaten to wreck the entire human enterprise. As Carl Jung wrote:

"It is not famine, not earthquakes, not microbes, not cancer, but man himself that is man's greatest danger to man, for the simple reason that there is no adequate protection against psychic epidemics, which are infinitely more devastating than the worst of natural catastrophes."

~ Carl Jung, "The Symbolic Life"

Basically, history is one psychic epidemic after another...

Expand full comment
River Ham's avatar

I think that the hardest part for me about this whole "ROGD isn't real" thing is that I experienced it... not in the "Oh you think your kid experienced it but they were actually feeling it all along and keeping it hidden" way (although that's a whole nother can of worms because I am 1000% positive they weren't hiding anything, being given completely free reign to express themselves as young children and even running counter to what we expected then) ... but in the *I* myself experienced it way. I was always tomboyish but never had any particular fear of being a woman when I grew up. I knew a lot of great women. I didn't see any downsides to being a woman. But when I started to actually BECOME A WOMAN (ie when puberty hit) I wanted no part of it. I fantasized about ways to get rid of my breasts. I was humiliated at having periods and didn't want to talk about it with anyone. Developing an eating disorder beat back a lot of those pesky puberty symptoms and in the back of my head I had this idea I could reverse it all completely and then let it start again at some other time when I was ready. (Yeah... I was blocking puberty before it was cool... )

I mean, those are the feelings these kids are having. They are freaking out over their developing bodies after having never shown any particular fear of becoming men or women adulthood. It's the BECOMING that is so hard... and talking to other friends of mine, it was hard for a lot of us. Your body changing, friend groups changing as interests change, responsibilities changing... the ONLY difference between what I felt as an adolescent and what my kids are feeling as an adolescent (and I know this - because I have read my daughter's diaries because I need to know what the hell is really going on here) is that I did not have strangers on the internet, teachers, and other friends telling me "Maybe it means you're transgender." The "trans" umbrella is now so huge that any struggling kid can see themselves under it - and "influencers" have them convinced their happiness lies in completely changing their bodies and identities.

I changed who I was - drastically - multiple times between middle school and graduating college. But thank god... none of those changes had a lasting impact on who I am today.

So being told this isn't real... when I lived it... is a lot to swallow.

Why is it only some "truths" that are supposed to be believed when we speak them? This is MY truth. And adolescence ... at its core... has not changed. If anything I think growing up right now is even MORE terrifying than when I was a kid. I am terrified for my kids... both of the realities they aere actually facing in this world, and what is being fed to them in terms of this trans business.

Expand full comment
44 more comments...

No posts