Discussion about this post

User's avatar
gaynor harding's avatar

my brother told us he was a girl more than 50 years ago. we were lost in a world of no information on this and suffered for decades in silence. we mourned. we mourned and we still mourn. my sibling is paralysed after the toll the hormones took on his body. estrogen was never meant to be taken by males. it caused strokes, heart attacks, embolisms and multiple sclerosis. men are 50 times more likely to suffer those effects. he has been paralysed for 37 years and lies, trapped in his body, in a long term care hospital. he can barely speak and can only move one arm.

this is the death of family member. he stopped being my brother, in his own mind, but he will always be my brother. he will be buried and will still be a male. he has no breasts anymore and a vagina that has closed. as with all paralysed people, he has lost all gender markers.

this whole thing makes me so mad and sad and has made me depressed and suicidal. i deal with it, but today i find it overwhelming with my PTSD to see it in the news and on social media all the bloody time.

we must stick together as a community to stop the medical aspect of this. sure, go ahead and be a tomboy or a feminine boy, wear makeup or no makeup, because that is just fashion anyway. but for heaven's sake, do not mess with your biology. many of us fight to keep our health, please do not make your health worse....on purpose, for not purpose.

btw. i do not believe in gender dysphoria. i believe the issue stems from some kind of trauma, and results in delusional thinking.

Expand full comment
distressed parent's avatar

Your essay is a compelling description of ineffable horror. In our family, our precious son seemed like he had beaten the trans OCD during high school before he fell prey to it freshman year of college (with the "help" of Planned Parenthood). His esteemed college then housed him with a biological woman. That colleges reinforce a harmful delusion gripping vulnerable young people is shameful. Your metaphor about a heartbroken parent struggling to not be dragged under by the waves of despair is spot-on. Every instinct we have is to help our troubled kids resist a sick culture that seeks to destroy them. PITT articles provide a life raft to hold onto during this long surreal storm.

Expand full comment
142 more comments...

No posts